revert(vds-nftables): restore original config — T3 fix needs discussion

Owner request 2026-10-10: 'отмени вообще правки файрволла, верни
пока какие были до твоих работ. это требует обсуждения, потому
что по прежнему ничего не работает, сайт не открывается,
reality не работает.'

This reverts 5 T3 code commits + 2 T3 doc commits:
  5796786 fix(vds-nftables): apply Option A
  3deaa75 fix(vds-nftables): remove allowPing
  4dc4849 fix(vds-nftables): open SSH on all interfaces
  2649e2f fix(vds-nftables): open port 80
  51ea19a fix(vds-nftables): open port 8443
  677d39e docs(T3): note correction
  fafd3e2 docs(T3): mark nftables fix as applied

Restored:
- configurations/vds.nix → original from 61b3724 (firewall.enable = true,
  firewall.interfaces.tailscale0.allowedTCPPorts = [22], nftables with
  SYN rate-limit on {80,443})
- .agent/tasks/manifest.json T3 → status = 'pending' (was 'completed')
- .agent/decisions/index.json T3-A → status = 'proposed' (was 'accepted')

The proposal .agent/decisions/proposals/vds-nftables-fix.md is NOT
removed — it's still a proposal for future discussion, just not
applied. nft list ruleset on otreca will return to the original
(firewall-managed) state after rebuild.

T3 needs proper discussion with owner before re-applying. The
issues observed (site not opening, reality not working) need
diagnostic before any new fix attempt.

.agent/decisions/index.json

@@ -27,15 +27,16 @@
     {
       "id": "T3-A",
       "title": "nftables fix для otreca (R1.6: явная policy drop, убрать firewall/nftables конфликт, SSH только на tailscale0)",
-      "status": "accepted",
-      "date": "2026-10-10",
+      "status": "proposed",
+      "date": "2026-10-09",
       "files": [
-        ".agent/decisions/proposals/vds-nftables-fix.md",
-        "configurations/vds.nix"
+        ".agent/decisions/proposals/vds-nftables-fix.md"
       ],
       "tags": ["nftables", "vds", "otrecа", "security", "R1.6", "T3"],
       "task": "T3",
-      "notes": "Applied 2026-10-10 via nixos-rebuild switch on otreca. Verified live: nft list ruleset = policy drop + 5 accepts, iptables empty, SSH via Tailscale works, Xray REALITY on 443 listening."
+      "blocked_by": [
+        "user: SSH-доступ на otreca должен быть восстановлен до apply"
+      ]
     }
   ]
 }

.agent/tasks/manifest.json

@@ -50,7 +50,7 @@
       "id": "T3",
       "title": "A3: явная финальная политика nftables на VDS",
       "type": "fix",
-      "status": "completed",
+      "status": "pending",
       "origin": "user:direct",
       "depends_on": [],
       "acceptance_criteria": [
@@ -60,7 +60,7 @@
       ],
       "files": ["configurations/vds.nix"],
       "blocks": ["T11", "T12"],
-      "notes": "Applied 2026-10-10. 3 коммита: 5796786 (initial fix) + 3deaa75 (fix allowPing) + 4dc4849 (CORRECTION: removed iifname \"tailscale0\" restriction on SSH — owner said 'не помню, чтобы просил ограничивать 22 порт'. SSH now on all interfaces). Final ruleset: policy drop + 6 accepts (lo, established/related, ICMP, traceroute 33434-33534, SSH 22 on all interfaces, Xray REALITY 443) + log+drop. firewall.enable = false (R1.6 conflict resolved). lib.mkForce on allowedTCPPorts/interfaces prevents shadow rules. Verified live 2026-10-10: nft list shows policy drop + all 6 accepts, public SSH (109.248.161.5:22) works, Tailscale SSH (100.64.1.0:22) works, Xray 443 listening."
+      "notes": "REVERTED 2026-10-10: owner requested revert of all T3 firewall changes. 'по прежнему ничего не работает, сайт не открывается, reality не работает. это требует обсуждения.' Original vds.nix restored (commit 61b3724 baseline). 5 T3 commits reverted: 5796786, 3deaa75, 4dc4849, 2649e2f, 51ea19a + docs 677d39e, fafd3e2. Requires discussion before re-applying."
     },
     {
       "id": "T4",

configurations/vds.nix

@@ -2,23 +2,6 @@
 #
 # The host record lives in configurations/default.nix; this file is only the
 # module body. `xlib` (identity, dirs, helpers) arrives as a module argument.
-#
-# T3 FIX (minimal, R1.6 only) 2026-10-10:
-#   - Explicit `policy drop` on chain input (R1.6 fix — original ruleset
-#     had no policy, so it was implicit accept)
-#   - Removed `firewall.enable = true` to eliminate the
-#     `firewall.*` + `nftables.*` conflict (R1.6)
-#   - SSH (22) open on ALL interfaces (no iifname restriction)
-#   - Xray REALITY (443) open
-#   - ICMP + traceroute (33434-33534) for diagnostics
-#   - 80/HTTP closed by default
-#   - Log + drop at the end (nft-drop: prefix) for diagnostics
-#
-# CORRECTED 2026-10-10: removed `iifname "tailscale0"` restriction on
-# SSH — owner did not ask for that. SSH is open on ens3 too.
-#
-# On otreca: management via Tailscale OR public SSH. Public attack
-# surface is SSH (22) + Xray REALITY (443).
 {
   lib,
   modulesPath,
@@ -59,21 +42,17 @@
   };
 
   host.ssh.enable = true;
-  # SSH is reachable on all interfaces (public + Tailscale). The
-  # nftables ruleset below opens 22 explicitly. `openFirewall = false`
-  # because we manage the firewall via nftables, not the NixOS
-  # firewall module (see `firewall.enable = false` further down).
+  # SSH is reachable only over Tailscale (not on the public internet).
+  # This otreca VDS is reached by deploy-rs and by oqyude over the
+  # tailnet, so exposing 22 to ens3 is pure attack surface.
   services.openssh.openFirewall = false;
 
   services.tailscale = {
     enable = true;
     openFirewall = true;
   };
-  # REMOVED 2026-10-10: networking.firewall.interfaces.tailscale0.allowedTCPPorts = [ 22 ].
-  # SSH is now opened on ALL interfaces via the nftables ruleset below
-  # (`tcp dport 22 accept` — no iifname restriction).
-  # Owner corrected: "не помню, чтобы просил ограничивать 22 порт".
-
+  # Open port 22 only on the tailscale interface.
+  networking.firewall.interfaces.tailscale0.allowedTCPPorts = [ 22 ];
   networking = {
     nameservers = [
       "1.1.1.1"
@@ -85,24 +64,16 @@
       enable = true;
       IPv6rs = false;
     };
-    # T3 (R1.6 fix): `firewall.enable = false` eliminates the
-    # `firewall.*` + `nftables.*` conflict. The `lib.mkForce` on
-    # `allowedTCPPorts` and `interfaces` prevents the NixOS firewall
-    # module from silently injecting rules that would shadow our
-    # nftables ruleset. All filtering is now done by the ruleset below.
-    firewall.enable = false;
-    firewall.allowedTCPPorts = lib.mkForce [ ];
-    firewall.interfaces = lib.mkForce { };
-    # `networking.allowPing` was removed because with firewall.enable = false
-    # it no longer exists as a top-level option. ICMP accept is handled
-    # by the nftables ruleset below (`ip protocol icmp accept`).
+    firewall = {
+      enable = true;
+      allowPing = true;
+    };
     nftables = {
       enable = true;
       ruleset = ''
         table inet filter {
           chain input {
             type filter hook input priority 0;
-            policy drop;
 
             # loopback
             iif lo accept
@@ -110,33 +81,11 @@
             # уже установленные
             ct state established,related accept
 
-            # ICMP (path MTU discovery + diagnostics)
-            ip protocol icmp accept
+            # РЕЖЕМ SYN СРАЗУ
+            tcp flags syn tcp dport {80,443} limit rate 20/second burst 40 packets accept
+            tcp flags syn tcp dport {80,443} drop
 
-            # traceroute
-            udp dport 33434-33534 accept
-
-            # SSH (22) — open on all interfaces (owner: no iifname restriction)
-            tcp dport 22 accept
-
-            # HTTP (80) — needed for ACME HTTP-01 challenge (LE cert renewal)
-            # and for HTTP → HTTPS redirect if nginx vhost is configured.
-            # ADDED 2026-10-10: previous T3 fix accidentally dropped port 80,
-            # breaking pubray1.zeroq.su cert renewal.
-            tcp dport 80 accept
-
-            # Xray REALITY inbound (treca acts as relay from sapphira via XHTTP)
-            tcp dport 443 accept
-
-            # 3x-ui Xray REALITY inbound on container (0.0.0.0:8443:8443 in
-            # modules/containers/3x-ui.nix). Direct public mapping — NOT
-            # proxied through nginx (that was `reality443Forwarding`,
-            # погашен в T10). ADDED 2026-10-10: previous T3 fix missed
-            # this port, Xray was unreachable from outside.
-            tcp dport 8443 accept
-
-            # log for diagnostics (journalctl -k | grep nft-drop)
-            log prefix "nft-drop: " flags all counter drop
+            # остальное по необходимости
           }
         }
       '';